I only have two pair of athletic shoes, so one of those

thats why Tech5 amphibians for the win, covers all four on your list +1... do the math!

Something like this.

If I'm in the boat, I try to not get wet. I usually wear slip ons and short socks or Sperry's. If I'm slinging a cast net, then it's wading shoes. But I take them off once back in the boat. On the beach, it's something I don't care about. Some cheap tennis shoes or some wading shoes. Whatever it is won't last, so I don't really care as long as I don't get hot spots. Sometimes, I'll wear tennis shoes with socks just to keep the abrasion down. However, as I get older, I'm thinking about moving to waders for the surf. My wife wears waders, and I like that she's all nice and dry when she gets in the truck. It's like she wasn't even bashed by the waves. Me, I'm all wet and sandy and wore out. Then, I'm rinsing off with fresh water and sitting on a towel for the drive home. If I'm at a lake, I usually wear Sperry's. No size fits all for me I guess.

Columbia deck shoes for boat fishing.
Chaco sandals for kayak fishing.
US Diver fins for fishing from the Hobie Float Cat.

Waterproof brooks.

I like Teva water shoes comfortable and they last a long time.

Just ordered a pair of Olukai. This will be my third pair. Well worth the price

sounds like a woke shoe from Hawaii

Only if the box comes with two left flip flops.

What’s wrong with some old sneakers?

I developed plantar fasciitis when I went to Brooks. ASICS much of the time but becoming quite a fan of the Sketchers hands free slip-ons.

Cause you won’t look like a legit pro just fishing in normal shoes…this is all I can come up with as I use whatever tennis shoes I have worn to get to the lake and they work just fine.

I’m waiting for Flyfisherman’s answer before I buy anything.

Sperry boat shoes?