I will be off for three days this weekend, (10/20 - 22). My wife has been wanting to go for a long weekend fishing trip. We are thinking about Caddo Lake or Broken Bow. Any thoughts on which one would be better this time of year as well as suggestions on where to stay (preferably on the lake). Thanks for any suggestions.

I'd probably go Broken Bow honestly. Caddo is so hit or miss it's crazy. Only been biting bout 2hrs a day lately. With this front idk what they will do but if u come caddo let me know. I will b out Saturday

We been catching some nice ones on caddo, but is hard to get around. Good frog bite going on....in the right place.... downloading a pic on my Facebook.... Allen's guide and tour service....
the kind I'm catching....solid fun fish!

Just got back an hour ago from 3 days at Broken Bow. Between the 2 of us we caught around 170 fishing 3 days from 8:00-Noon all on top water. Had a blast and thinking about heading back next weekend if I can manage another couple days off work.

Well I ain't caught 170 in 12 hours of fishing

Ain't worth making a drive to our lake right now which sucks. Most people from out of town wanna catch fish instantly when getting there. Plus none want deal with our mess. But heck of a nice punch bite I got on yesterday!!

Definitely an experience I haven�t had either before now. We were fishing 60-80 fow and you would have thought it was sand bass schooling to see all the surface activity. It was our first trip up there but definitely not our last. No big ones to brag about but definitely had the numbers up to around 3 pounds.

Yes Mudd....punch bite has been good as well....as far as dealing with our salivina...staying close or in LA is best!

Broken Bow.

Sounds like a lot of fun!

I kinda wanna go Broken Bow myself now

WOW! Sounds like Broken Bow might be the place to go. Any suggestions on where to stay? Are there any cabins on the water?

I haven't hit that type of fishing timing-wise at Broken Bow for several years, it can be a blast, when they shut off on top, pull out a small to medium spoon and you can continue to whack them and typically they're a little bigger below the small ones. I have a cabin out there, and there are honestly a ton of them to choose from. Here's ours: http://beaversbendgetaways.com/cabins/dry-creek-lodge/

Good luck!

http://www.wildernesslakefrontresort.com/index.html @ Broken Bow stayed here in June w/Family enjoyed it and caught a Bunch of Bass no Smallie's though north end of Lake.

Think Broken Bow should fish pretty good this time of year; especially if your wife is fishing...the catching will be easier there if she can work a split shot senko or a whopper plopper