The hole will be proportionate to your hookset. You want the hook to peirce the fish. The rip/tear is from the pressure that the angler puts during the hooks set and then as the angler/fish are fighting one another.. Example how many have put a fish cull ring in a fish. They have no holes, you puncture a hole with the clip, later you go to cull that fish and you lift that fish up by the string. Did you notice the tear the fish now has from the added pressure that you and the fish put on the portion of the mouth as they shake back and forth. Mmm hook and cull ring do the same thing. This is simple physics in my book.

I like the trokar, I do not have to set the hook hard at all to get penetration, thus have a less chance of tearing a bigger hole in the fish. All hooks will and can assit in tearing a whole. You want the best, sharpest hook for the best penetration with minimal effort.

My .02

I bought a bunch and threw them all away after losing fish after fish on them

as for the hooksets, those that are watching MLF, what Tak, Jones, Erhler and others, they do not cross their eyes, they don't real down and go wham. Granit you see some go on point but I don't think they cross their eyes at all that put steady quick pressure on their hookset. Just saying. I like the trokar and really like their flipping hooks, which is what I use the majority of the time anyway.