Bread works great for carp in some situations. And I would never laugh at anyone that has figured out how to catch fish. We are all amateurs on some species out there. I just thought you might want to see if there were big ones around.

Osbornfishing is a master at this as he's caught records in just about every category of fish. I have read his book too!!

Carp and buffs are always fun to catch. Even for kiddos. My kids are now experimenting on what they can use to catch them on now. So far we have had luck with marshmallows (pink beat out white) corn, white bread, gummy bears and sour gummy worms.

Definitely a White Armur , the body shape and eye location lets me come to this decision .

Thanks, Is a white amur a carp? Never heard of them.

White Amur is a common name for Grass Carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella).