Both are very effective. I like green pumpkin magic on baby brush hog. Couldn’t find it and bought yarby mud bug. Same results. Tilapia magic is very good in cleaner water

I got obsessed with flukes for a good couple of years. I bought every color Zoom had possible.in flukes. Even several other fluke style baits made by other companies. If you want to keep thinking there is this "magical color" that catches more fish than others, than my all means knock yourself out. Report your results with your information to back it too please.

You don't need me to tell you what I have found to work the best because you have already tested out every color Zoom makes according to your post so you already know what works for you and what doesn't. I know of quite a few of Zoom colors that work better for me than you one you like but you just need to stick to what works best for you. You are the only one that I have ever heard of that has tried EVERY color that Zoom makes. I do have 5 Zoom colors that work well at the lake I fish and I stick with those.

Well grandbasslayer what is your answer? What colors don't catch fish? Im still waiting on your response so I don't waste money on colors that are for fishermen only.