I have not fished Fayette all that much but the times that I have I have always caught plenty of BIG Bluegill and Redear! I have fished Dunlap a lot and have caught some good quality fish there but I would have to give Fayette the vote for having more big sunfish. Dunlap was a very good lake to fish prior to the dam break. I have fished Dunlap a few times since it's dam break and I would have to agree with Chuck. The fishing is not all that good.

I can see both points made for both lakes. I have seen over the years plenty of great post and catches from both Fayette and Dunlap. I do not target sunfish. I have fished both Dunlap and Fayette for bass over the years and have caught plenty of them on both lakes. However I do feel that Fayette has more quality fish than Dunlap based on the past post and reports. It's a shame the dam had to break and I know first hand that the bass fishing has gotten bad since the dam break. A lot of structure had simply vanished off of Dunlap not to mention water levels. The come back for Lake Dunlap is going to be slow. As for Fayette I hope it can maintain the quality of fish it has.