El pescador and Turneffe are both great options, but they are $$$. If you are on a budget,like me, stay on San Pedro at any hotel near town and fish with Omar Arceo, Omar's Freelance Fishing (facebook). I fished with him twice in the past few years. You can just walk to his dock and take off to the reef or lagoon side depending on if you want bones, permit, or tarpon and what the water levels and clarity are that day. ~$350/day last time and he put me on a ton of bones and I missed a permit opportunity due to my slow/inaccurate casting.