Sure-Shot vs DK

Anyone here ever use sure-shot punch bait? How is it compared to the old DK? Since the change in DK I haven't caught a thing on it, so I was looking for something new/different.

MY experiance:

DK (Old only) Channels

Sure Shot: Blues

My ratio is about 8 to one for Sure Shot over DK's

Remember, MY EXPERIANCE ONLY!!!!!!!

Hooker is the sure shot Pro, if anyone would know he would.

Sure Shot will catch more blues.

Neither use fresh shad

I prefer Sure Shot.

I would have to strongly agree with catfishd fresh shad. All cats eat shad.

What did DK change in their punch bait?

Doesn't have the strong smell anymore and it's like slightly damp cotton the best way I can describe it.

Doesn't work as well as it once did!

I won't be buying any more.

Rather spend my money on a proven product that someone cares enough to produce, and not change, and cares enough to keep their customers, instead of cut corners and not care if the customer likes it or not!

Sure Shot, hands down. Lots more shad in it and I catch both blues and channels on it.

Actually Sure Shot is what got me to making my own punch bait. I have used both DK and Sure Shot with SS beating out DK most of the time. I am sure out of the loop on how DK is made But Benny is the one who gave me the plan on how to make good punch bait. You have to do it some to find out how much work there is to making good punch bait. As to Benny's shad not bein fresh, no it ain't raw shad as that would just spoil and make a stinkin mess, but it is cured and never frozen shad. There is a science to putting several organic ingredients together and getting some shelf life without the rotted stinking mess some people think is punch bait.

Where do you find sure shot at?

http://www.catfishbait.net/

Benny lives in Decatur last I heard. I used to buy it at his house when I still fished punchbait. That stuff works good, but I prefer catching my bait now. Only fresh shad and perch for me now. Check out his website in the last post to find out how to contact him if you are interested in driving there to pick some up. He is a nice guy to visit with also.

Sure shot

I'm about to place an order with Benny. I haven't bought any bait from him in a couple of years at least, because I still had some from the last few gallons I bought, and I have been using mostly shad for catfish. I do use punchbait under birds or around shallow timber however, and it works great. Good way to put several eating size channel cats in the boat quickly.