Pumpkin Pie

Am I the only one who says NO to pumpkin pie?

I’m fine with pumpkin bread, lukewarm on pumpkin spice coffee...but I would rather have no dessert than have pumpkin pie.

Anyone else?

Probably not the only one, but definitely in the minority I would think.

It's disgusting.

Pumpkin pie is okay. Pecan pie is the GOAT.

Not a fan of pumpkin anything. I agree - I'll pass on dessert if pumpkin pie is the only option.

From the Connoisseur of vinnie sausage.

My great grandma's pumpkin pie was to die for.

Liked it as a kid then I grew up, will eat it if it’s the only pie around

Sweet potato pie

I like it with some cool whip over the top.

It's way down the list for me, if it is the only dessert then maybe.
Buttermilk pie is #1 for me.

Not plain ole pumpkin but pumpkin chiffon,,heck yes.

I like it icebox cold.

Yes...lemon icebox pie. So good.

Pumpkin...not so much.

Not a pie fan at all.

I like pie

Made a pumpkin mousse pie one year with ginger snap cookie crust
Disappeared quickly; even those that don’t like pumpkin pie loved it.

Pumpkin nothing,...

I agree!

you people are weird.

I have to draw the line somewhere.

Most are on fentanyl

very likely.

Pumpkin pie is a great side to go with a big bowl of cool whip

All day err day.

I’ve eaten it the last two years but never in the past because I always thought it was nasty. The way people go crazy over it I thought I must have missed something so I tried it. It’s eatable but it’s certainly no game changer. Oh yeah, it needs whip cream.

I like it, and make one traditional for the family gathering, and a chiffon version just for me to have at the house. Goes great with a big dollop of heavy whipped cream on top.

Is that how she passed?

It's alright, but I prefer pumpkin cheesecake.

Anybody grow up poor and couldn't afford pecans? Just had syrup pies, ie pecan pie with out the pecans. Not bad.

Nope. We were poor, but in South Georgia, pecans are plentiful.

Same for peaches and tomatoes.

We were poor so we would go pick pecans in the woods.

Pecans are free and get the kids outta your hair for an hour or two while you send them to go fill up a sack or two. And then it's something to keep them busy at night after dark... cracking, shelling, and picking.

Pecan pie is the GOAT. I haven’t had pumpkin pie in years. My family always has both.

One bite of pumpkin pie has lasted me a life time

Old age. She was a great lady.

Grandma always put out 5 types of pies on Thanksgiving and Christmas, all homemade, all from ingredients from her farm. Pumpkin, Apple, Peach, Mincemeat, and Rhubarb. Never cared for the rhubarb. Her Mincemeat was the best.

Pumpkin pie was good hot or cold. Had to have an equal depth of whipped cream on top though.

Speaking of pies, has anyone ever tried the butter cream pie that Pappy's Hamburgers on Mockingbird serves? Prolly the best tasting pie that I've had in a long time.

Love any cobblers or pies that were homemade . Especially love Strawberry Rhubarb pie !! Had to be fresh tho . I've had store bought from Albertsons Grocery but eat it quick cause 2 - 3 days max before mold sets in . No more store bought unless it's Sarah Lees' Apple , peach , or Cherry !!! Uummm !!

Y'all have the two best pies wrong though. It's pecan and buttermilk.

Pecan Pie is one of the few exceptions, otherwise no dessert.

Pumpkin pie is ok but I have to have cool whip on it

I don’t care for pumpkin pie or anything pumpkin for that matter. Custard, apple, blueberry and buttermilk pies are my faves

Agree with grandma; the best pies after all the turkey, ham, stuffing/dressing are acidic to cleanse the palate
Strawberry Rhubarb
Key Lime
Mince Pie
Lemon

Best pie I ever had was Butterscotch cream pie at Tiffany’s.

haven't seen that one for a while, will request it fri.
I have some pie every weekend, any at tiffanys will do just fine by me. the pumpkin is awesome with vanilla bean ice cream or whipped cream/cool whip/stuff in a can.

pumpkin pie is great, but sweet potato is best

A lot of the places around here serve what they call peach cobbler. In reality, it is peach pie filling and bisquick.

I think they should be arrested....false advertising.

Use to like it not anymore.I like pecan pie and a cold beer.after Thanksgiving.

sweet tater pie is better than punkin...but nanner puddin' is the best...

Its a good.

Pumpkin pie ..I can take it or leave it.

i mix pumpkin filling
with
cinnamon - ginger - condensed milk
&
eat it instead
of a lot of sugar stuff

i wud like tu spale like that

Nothing pumpkin for me ever.

Love me some punk'n pie!

Second runner up is pecan, with huckleberry pie following close behind.

Same here!

Depending on your family this might be an option though!

No punkin pie on thanksgiving ! It’s blasphemy! Un heard of !! What’s next tofu turkey !!

Pumpkin pie is the best. Gotta have a big heaping scoop of whipped cream on top.

Not a fan of pecan pie. When I was a little kid, I threw up after a big meal. I blamed the pecan pie I had for dessert and haven’t had a bite since.

I love Pumpkin Pie. Also Pecan Pie as well.

I don't eat any kind of pie.

Pecan pie
Nothing else matters

Awesome anytime. Holidays, breakfast, whenever.

Thanksgiving. The grown kids like a coconut pie and the grandkids want a chocolate pie.
I will buy myself a pecan pie.
With the price of pecans I can buy one cheaper than we can make one.
Any other pie we cook our own

Love them both!!

Plus 1
Pie Peddlers in the Glenrose Square makes an awesome Buttermilk Pie.

Not my favorite.

Not a big fan unless it is the type of pumpkin pie with the cream cheese then bring it on.

^^^This^^^