I really wanted to like pedal drives and have tried a few out over the years. For fishing they are great, enough stability to stand, carrying a lot more gear, and more or less hands free to fish. The downside in my mind were all the other things. First and foremost was the weight of all the wider boats. If I can't lift it over my head, I'm going to have to get a pickup or a trailer. Well I acquired a trailer for when I need to take multiple kayaks (sister's grandkids), but the rest of the time its just me. I've slowed down to fishing only about 50 days a year over the last 6 years. At one time, I was fishing/kayaking 100+ days a year.
Kayaks are supposed to be simple. Load, unload, fish, or just paddle. Where I fished for years a pedal drive just wouldn't work without breaking stuff and in my case, I would have probably had to be rescued if I had pedal drive. Those wider boats are a beast to paddle into wind, current, or rough water and I've seen too many pedal drives break on oyster bars, mangrove roots, and every where else the fish seem to be. To me a skinny kayak is much more stable in the worst conditions. The wind has much less effect sitting so much lower to the water and so much less kayak sticking above the surface.
I haven't ruled one out but if I get too old to lift, I might just get something big and heavy with either pedals or spotlock for the Bass Kayak Tour.
Headed back over to the Everglades (where paddled kayaks excel) and Florida Keys next month and counting down the days.
PM me if anyone wants to join me... bring your paddle.