Texas Fishing Forum

Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12?

Posted By: bell0347

Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/07/22 10:47 PM

If I go with a stand-alone 24v it will require a new tray and shifting things in the bilge around. If I go with 2 x 12v in series I can drop them right in. Price difference is like $50 on the batts but I would need a new tray making the 24v about $130 more. 24v comes with single bank charger, 2x12’s I would need a new 3 bank charger which will be around $200-$250. So, price is a wash really. Anybody see or know of a reason for the bigger 24v to be a better set up?
Posted By: grout-scout

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/07/22 11:08 PM

Downfall to the 24v, should it go bad when you need the boat, you’re buying 2 new batteries and hunting down a 12v chargers to charge. I would think you already have the 12v charger, but if you fish out of town, maybe not.


2 - 12v’s and you have one break when needed, you can slip a cheap 12v in its place for the time being.


Biggest downfall that I’m seeing on the 24v’s is most aren’t that big of amp hours. I rather have 2 100ah batteries on the TM, than a single 24v 50-60ah. These 24v batteries do interest me, but I’ll probably stick with the dual batteries.
Posted By: bell0347

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/07/22 11:20 PM

I’m looking at Amped outdoors. They offer a 24v 80ah or a 12v 80ah that’s in a group 27 case. I’ve heard a 24v may last longer due to cell balancing and charging being being more consistent but the same guy said if space was a concern then I could get two 24v 50ah and wire parallel which seems like I’d be right back at the balancing issues 🤷🏻‍♂️
Posted By: grout-scout

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/08/22 12:35 AM

From listening to several of the professional anglers, they are running dual 24v batteries. Granted most of us don’t need that much battery.


80ah is pretty decent sized for most of us.


Edit: just looked at the amp webpage, nice looking battery. Comes with a 10amp charger, which is nice. Their prices are pretty good, I kind of prefer having Bluetooth, but can’t say that it’s necessary. Most of the 24v that I’ve seen were a bit more expensive and having 2 duals made more sense. These Amps might change my thinking, but then I go back to the “what if it breaks”.

I’m not really seeing any reason to talk you out of that 24v.
Posted By: prosise

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/08/22 01:49 AM

2x 12v lithium batteries. Just my .02... 2x 100ah batteries and you can fish two days without worrying.
Posted By: Will.i.am

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/08/22 02:06 AM

I sell a couple different brands and the singles and mutliples have pro and cons just like anything does. Yes if the single cuts out on you it can ruin your day but same goes for tryin to run a 24v motor on 12v power as its not getting very much done. Depending on the brand and space you have some choose the singles. You also have to factor in your charging situtation, do you wanna run a onboard system or multi plug ins and deal with an individual charger? When looking at sales for me I would say the singles vs the 24v or 36v is pretty even, its just comes down to your budget and brand preference. Also depending on your style of fishing 50ah will get ya 2-2.5 days of fishing on a single charge, if you're running on 80-100% all day or fishing heavy current recommend 100ah. Give Ionic a look I'm running this deal for a bit longer, they have built in bluetooth and I awlays tell people if your gonna make an investment why not get the most tech out you dollar.

https://fishtacklemarine.com/collections/ionic-batteries
[Linked Image]
Posted By: Bobby Milam

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/08/22 02:22 AM

Originally Posted by grout-scout
Downfall to the 24v, should it go bad when you need the boat, you’re buying 2 new batteries and hunting down a 12v chargers to charge. I would think you already have the 12v charger, but if you fish out of town, maybe not.


2 - 12v’s and you have one break when needed, you can slip a cheap 12v in its place for the time being.


Biggest downfall that I’m seeing on the 24v’s is most aren’t that big of amp hours. I rather have 2 100ah batteries on the TM, than a single 24v 50-60ah. These 24v batteries do interest me, but I’ll probably stick with the dual batteries.


I am no expert on batteri3s but I think I saw the ad on facebook and someone said the same thing about replacing one with a cheap 12v in emergency and they said you could not link the 2 different type together so I would check with them about that.
I just repowered my old Champion with a new larger 4 stroke which weighs more and I can see the difference in how low the transom sits in the water so I am considering making the change to free up the weight from 4 heavy batteries to 2 lighter batteries.
Posted By: Will.i.am

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/08/22 02:28 AM

Originally Posted by Bobby Milam
Originally Posted by grout-scout
Downfall to the 24v, should it go bad when you need the boat, you’re buying 2 new batteries and hunting down a 12v chargers to charge. I would think you already have the 12v charger, but if you fish out of town, maybe not.


2 - 12v’s and you have one break when needed, you can slip a cheap 12v in its place for the time being.


Biggest downfall that I’m seeing on the 24v’s is most aren’t that big of amp hours. I rather have 2 100ah batteries on the TM, than a single 24v 50-60ah. These 24v batteries do interest me, but I’ll probably stick with the dual batteries.


I am no expert on batteri3s but I think I saw the ad on facebook and someone said the same thing about replacing one with a cheap 12v in emergency and they said you could not link the 2 different type together so I would check with them about that.
I just repowered my old Champion with a new larger 4 stroke which weighs more and I can see the difference in how low the transom sits in the water so I am considering making the change to free up the weight from 4 heavy batteries to 2 lighter batteries.


That's correct you can't run a lead acid and lithium in series or parallel, with some brand you are able to jump a lead acid from a lithium but that's dependent on the type of cells and how the bms is programmed in the lithium.
Posted By: grout-scout

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/08/22 02:33 AM

Originally Posted by Bobby Milam
Originally Posted by grout-scout
Downfall to the 24v, should it go bad when you need the boat, you’re buying 2 new batteries and hunting down a 12v chargers to charge. I would think you already have the 12v charger, but if you fish out of town, maybe not.


2 - 12v’s and you have one break when needed, you can slip a cheap 12v in its place for the time being.


Biggest downfall that I’m seeing on the 24v’s is most aren’t that big of amp hours. I rather have 2 100ah batteries on the TM, than a single 24v 50-60ah. These 24v batteries do interest me, but I’ll probably stick with the dual batteries.


I am no expert on batteri3s but I think I saw the ad on facebook and someone said the same thing about replacing one with a cheap 12v in emergency and they said you could not link the 2 different type together so I would check with them about that.
I just repowered my old Champion with a new larger 4 stroke which weighs more and I can see the difference in how low the transom sits in the water so I am considering making the change to free up the weight from 4 heavy batteries to 2 lighter batteries.



You can series them for the short term, not long term. (We’re talking something along the lines of fishing a tournament and you have no option, except to buy a lead acid to get you through the tournament.) The higher voltage lithium would always be sending power to the lower voltage lead acid. If you saw that on a Champion boat forum, might have been me saying it.


Which model champ do you have and what did you put on it?
Posted By: Jersey Dan

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/08/22 04:41 AM

The Ionic battery is a complete game changer. You will never buy regular batteries again.
Posted By: David Welcher

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/08/22 11:14 AM

Just get you a 24V and a charger for it.
You won't regret it.
Posted By: Bobby Milam

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/08/22 03:23 PM

Originally Posted by grout-scout
Originally Posted by Bobby Milam
Originally Posted by grout-scout
Downfall to the 24v, should it go bad when you need the boat, you’re buying 2 new batteries and hunting down a 12v chargers to charge. I would think you already have the 12v charger, but if you fish out of town, maybe not.


2 - 12v’s and you have one break when needed, you can slip a cheap 12v in its place for the time being.


Biggest downfall that I’m seeing on the 24v’s is most aren’t that big of amp hours. I rather have 2 100ah batteries on the TM, than a single 24v 50-60ah. These 24v batteries do interest me, but I’ll probably stick with the dual batteries.


I am no expert on batteri3s but I think I saw the ad on facebook and someone said the same thing about replacing one with a cheap 12v in emergency and they said you could not link the 2 different type together so I would check with them about that.
I just repowered my old Champion with a new larger 4 stroke which weighs more and I can see the difference in how low the transom sits in the water so I am considering making the change to free up the weight from 4 heavy batteries to 2 lighter batteries.



You can series them for the short term, not long term. (We’re talking something along the lines of fishing a tournament and you have no option, except to buy a lead acid to get you through the tournament.) The higher voltage lithium would always be sending power to the lower voltage lead acid. If you saw that on a Champion boat forum, might have been me saying it.


Which model champ do you have and what did you put on it?

A 176. Put a Tohatsu 140 on it
Posted By: Tiltman

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/09/22 11:08 AM

Originally Posted by Jersey Dan
The Ionic battery is a complete game changer. You will never buy regular batteries again.



I had Amped and switched to Ionics, went from single 36 to 3 12’s for me to balance the weight in the boat.

The cranking battery from Ionics is outstanding

If in DFW I can also supply Ionics from our location in Wylie
Posted By: hopalong

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/09/22 11:31 AM

I have 3 ionic for my force tm, haven't got to use them much so far, outboard gave out.

I too suggest go with the 2 12's.
Posted By: bell0347

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 09/10/22 02:13 PM

I pulled the trigger on the 2 x 12v, 80ah setup from Amped. The price for the ah's and internal construction seemed really good and I got a 10% discount, customer service seems really good as well. I know I don't have the bluetooth functionality but I picked up a monitor that mounts on the dash for less than $50. I can see how it would be better to have one set of cells controlled by one BMS but by going with the two batt setup I can drop them right in to the trays where my old batteries are and will work best for boat balancing. I also like the idea that I can add or remove a single battery in case of a failure or to get me out of a pinch.

Really appreciate all the input guys!

Now, which chargers are you guys using? I have the NOCO 3 bank in my amazon cart, anyone have anything good or bad to say about it or have another suggestion?
Posted By: Bweidler

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 11/03/22 07:07 PM

I like single batteries, less headache. check out this one. https://www.impulselithium.com/product/24v-60ah-platinum-series-lifepo4-lithium-battery/
Posted By: coachallentca

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 11/03/22 07:45 PM

Originally Posted by bell0347
I pulled the trigger on the 2 x 12v, 80ah setup from Amped. The price for the ah's and internal construction seemed really good and I got a 10% discount, customer service seems really good as well. I know I don't have the bluetooth functionality but I picked up a monitor that mounts on the dash for less than $50. I can see how it would be better to have one set of cells controlled by one BMS but by going with the two batt setup I can drop them right in to the trays where my old batteries are and will work best for boat balancing. I also like the idea that I can add or remove a single battery in case of a failure or to get me out of a pinch.

Really appreciate all the input guys!

Now, which chargers are you guys using? I have the NOCO 3 bank in my amazon cart, anyone have anything good or bad to say about it or have another suggestion?



I have been using Noco chargers for a while and I love them...I had one charger go bad and the replaced it free for me.
Posted By: Fish Killer

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 11/03/22 08:01 PM

Im on the fence about going with 2 of the 12v 50 amp

One thing I see is having to run two different charging systems since I want to keep my lead cell for the cranking battery
Posted By: SteezMacQueen

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 11/03/22 10:17 PM

Originally Posted by Fish Killer
Im on the fence about going with 2 of the 12v 50 amp

One thing I see is having to run two different charging systems since I want to keep my lead cell for the cranking battery

Couldn’t you run one of the Minnkota chargers that you can set separately for each battery…and have one plug to plug to get it all charged?

I have flooded lead acid batteries for the Ultrex, a spiral cell AGM for the cranking battery, and a 50Ah lithium for everything else…including pumps, lighting, graphs, stereo system. One charger charges them all. It’s a MinnKota 460.
Posted By: Grapvine Homer

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 11/04/22 02:00 AM

Noco will do the job . i use the ionic 4 bank really does well
Posted By: hopalong

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 11/04/22 07:10 PM

Originally Posted by Fish Killer
Im on the fence about going with 2 of the 12v 50 amp

One thing I see is having to run two different charging systems since I want to keep my lead cell for the cranking battery



noco or minn kota precision both will charge lithiums, I use the precision 440 with mine.
Posted By: ogles824 (aka Lakewaydr50)

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 11/05/22 02:46 PM

Looking in to this too, I figure my lead acid batteries maybe have a couple of years left and it will be time to look at buying lithiums.
I read an article in one of the bass fishing publications a year or so ago where they studied a few aspects of running lithiums vs the others and one of the things that was mentioned is they talked about a guy that put lithium batteries in his boat and he decided to see how long they'd last on a steady wide open run. I want to say he ran 13.5 hours and he finally gave up, don't know the amp hour rating or voltage he was running, but I thought that was awesome.
I'm an industrial mechanic by trade and use a lot of lithium battery powered tools with the latest lithium technology. They'll run pretty much 100% and fall off a cliff when they die; either all or nothing. I figure lithium batteries in a boat will be the same.
Posted By: grout-scout

Re: Lithium 24v stand alone or 2x12? - 11/05/22 02:55 PM

I keep thinking about getting a 24v 100ah for the trolling motor, the price isn’t all that bad considering. If I could find a 36v 100ah affordable, I’d definitely get it.
© 2024 Texas Fishing Forum