I have an Ego S2 Slider and really like it but they do have a load capacity and it varies on how far the handle it extended. The handle part of the net hoop is plastic and a big red will break it. That's how mine broke but Ego does sell replacement parts.
I've been using one of the basic no frills aluminum frame nets I found on the side of the highway. It does the job.
What are you netting that is breaking the EGO S2? I've had several 9s and a DD in mine in the last year and a half with no problems at all. Oh and a 20 lb red fish!
When I said "I" it was actually my daughter's boyfriend at the time. *blink* It was a bull red, maybe 35-40lb range. I guess some folks have heebie-jeebies landing a fish that size by hand. I later found out on Ego's website they list the load capacity. Lesson learned.
By looking at the assembly you think the frame runs through the entire length of the plastic handle but it does not. The part that screws onto the handle is actually just an insert and it's all held together by the plastic handle. One of these days I'll get around to actually ordering it.
Anyways, I still think Ego is a good net, the extending handle is awesome.