Thanks for all the replies. I think I'll try downsizing next time. They did pull the worm down on a few bites so I guess it was just short strikers. Was starting to have some serious doubts about my hook choice as I know a lot of guys throw straight shank for worms vs EWG. But I figure the EWG would actually improve hookups with all that extra bite.
If you swing a time or two and miss the fish the worm will pull down, fish or no fish. Typically after you swing once & miss the next time you swing harder. If a perch or small bass has the tail the worm will pull down on the hook.
Also I am not a fan of the EWG hooks. I lost a fish at CB two springs ago that was 13-15# on a Mag Fluke on a 6/0 Owner Jungle Wide Gap hook. That hook has a bigger gap that any hook of its size. I felt the bite, I reeled down & got all the slack out, I hit the fish as hard as I could and she came up and jumped. The bait came flying back at me. When I got it back the big Fluke was balled up on the point of the hook. All she had was the tip of the point. The barb never made it into her.
I still get mad every time I think about that fish.
I called a friend of mine from Cali that has landed three over 18 pounds and probably a dozen over 13. Two of his 18's were the same fish one year apart on Lake Dixon. He is uses a T-rigged soft plastic lure that makes a Mag Fluke look like a finesse bait. He told me he had the same problem with EWG hooks so he switched to an old school round bend hook and it increased his hooking percentage.
Bass fishing is not an exact science. You can use an extra heavy rod, 80# braid, a 7/0 hook and you will still lose a fish from time to time. It has a lot to do with how the bait is turned in the fish's mouth when you jerk.