Posted By: mikep
Boat opinions - 04/01/18 11:15 PM
I’m looking at buying a new to me boat.. I’ve narrowed down between a 2005 Basscat Puma with 250 Verado and a 2005 Ranger Z21 w/250 HPDI.. I’m not real worried about speed..
250 Verado has 338 hours
250 HPdi has 168 hours
Let me hear your likes/Dislike .
Thanks
If that hpdi is all original that is a garage kept gem. That's some low hours. The ranger is a little bigger boat, more stable. The puma is faster. Both great boats but if the price is similar I'd go with the ranger.
Posted By: ezbassin
Re: Boat opinions - 04/02/18 12:15 AM
Drive both and fish out of both and see which you like best.
Posted By: lucky55
Re: Boat opinions - 04/02/18 12:31 AM
Someone I know has the same ranger, nice boat, tons of storage space. Heavy, stable riding boat. Not familiar with the cat though.
Oh yea he did blow motor around 500 hours, could be fluke but .....
Posted By: mikep
Re: Boat opinions - 04/02/18 12:47 AM
Yea I’ve heard several dislikes about the HPDI, is there something to that causes the dislike? Something to fix or address to keep it from shelling out? Can the motor be updated ??anything helps .. appreciate it
Posted By: lucky55
Re: Boat opinions - 04/02/18 01:13 AM
I was in boat when it blew, regular service, ran great just randomly died. No explanation from mechanic. He put brand new sho on it and has never looked back, the new 4 stroke sho is awesome on that boat now.
Posted By: mikep
Re: Boat opinions - 04/02/18 02:00 AM
No experience with the verado? Same year model 2005?
Nothing wrong with the hpdi. Get all the filters and routine maintenance done. I know some with 1000+ hours
Posted By: scumfrogg
Re: Boat opinions - 04/02/18 04:42 AM
The hpdi got an update in 07 i believe that corrected the issues. The 200 hpdi is indestructible, for some reason the 250 & 300’s have more issues. That said get filters and routine maintenance done and they are great motors
Posted By: BassLakeFork
Re: Boat opinions - 04/02/18 10:00 AM
My HPDI experience was a bit miserable........
2007 200 HPDI blew 4 years ago. Replaced power head for $10k, then blew a again one year later. Got new SHO and all seems to be good.
Posted By: basshc
Re: Boat opinions - 04/02/18 10:49 AM
Ranger had a 2005 hpdi ran hard till 2018 traded for new skeeter
Posted By: GeoFisher
Re: Boat opinions - 04/02/18 02:19 PM
My 09 HPDI lost #6 cylinder back in February. I bought it with 118 hours on it in Dec 2013 and it blew with 402 hours. I have heard nightmare stories about folks losing HPDI powerheads with less than 200 hours. That being said, I also know folks who have HPDI's with 500+ hours on them and one with almost 1000 hours. It's a carp shoot with any 2 stroke in my opinion. You just never know.
Started not to post this. Im not asking for trouble. my 2007 225 HPDI 1100 hrs. runs like a top. No ethanal gas, Ring free. Gets used a lot. Ranger Z20.
Posted By: Tex5000
Re: Boat opinions - 04/06/18 08:54 PM
Check to see if the HPDI has has the updates on the oil pump etc.
Can’t go wrong with a ranger... low hours too
Posted By: UTDmiller
Re: Boat opinions - 04/06/18 09:28 PM
My HPDI experience was a bit miserable........
2007 200 HPDI blew 4 years ago. Replaced power head for $10k, then blew a again one year later. Got new SHO and all seems to be good.
10k?
got a 225 rebuilt for 6, thats insane