Peanut butter pie.

Beat together..
8 oz cream cheese
1 cup smooth peanut butter
1/2 c sugar
2 teasp vanilla

Beat 1 cup heavy cream, and fold half of it into the peanut butter mixture then the rest. Fold into the precooked crust and chill 4 hours before serving.

Gonna try this

Just added another recipe to the "notes" file...
Thanks Kat!

Hey Kat, when you mention folding in the heavy cream, do you mean with a rubber spatula or wooden spoon or does it matter?

sprinkle chocolate 'chips' on top..

Doesn't matter. Just don't beat it to death.

I love PB pie!

nvr knew there was such a thing. sounds good! thanks!

Going to make this and try that tomorrow

Sweet Baby Infant Jesus....i'm going to have to try this!!!!!! THANK YOU!!!!

Y'all, I can't stress to you just HOW GOOD this pie is. Now I just need to make some hot fudge to drizzle over the top.

Peanut butter pie is my all time favorite. If you don't want to beat the heavy cream cool whip turns out good too!

Yep. I'm a dork and don't think of it, but yes, cool whip would work just fine. Just an 8 oz tub.

my daughter makes this its great

I just seen this part of the forum!!!! Hooked now....

Well I finally got around to trying this since my best friend loves Peanut Butter pies.

OUTSTANDING! Will be making it again soon. May add some milk chocolate chips/chunks or top with reeses pieces.

Thank Kattelyn

Thank you for the feedback! I love hearing folks enjoy my stuff!

Sounds awesome

I'm making this tomorrow after church!!!! Yum!

Do you make whipped cream out of the cream?

Yes. you can also swap it out for an 8 oz tub of cool whip.

Thanks, can't see waiting 4 hrs. though, don't think can wait that long. Might put in the freezer for an hour.

I wouldn't put it in the freezer. I've done it for as little as an hour in the fridge. You just want it to set up a bit. The longer it sets, the firmer it gets.

I have done this up without a pie crust, just in four small bowls with toasted pecan and graham cracker crumbles on top. We can hurt ourselves with this pie. And what's worse is that it is so easy to make with stuff I always keep on hand anyway.

I am soundly anti Cool Whip. That stuff is one molecule away from becoming plastic. Real whip cream for us.

Okay I made this for the youth group at church dessert auction and this pie was a huge hit!!! I made some tiny ones for home too, thank you for sharing

That sounds good, goons give that a try

Told my wife about the pie a week ago from last Sunday, the grand kids were there and wanted her to make it right then. I told them I would make it this week. Wife beat me to it, she made two this morning, making me wait. Will report back tonight.

Finally got to try it. Was great, after a couple bites grated a little nutmeg on it. I like that.

Hey y'all. Tried something today that's out of this world good. Substitute that peanut butter for cookie butter.

Cookie butter pie. You're welcome.

My wife has made this for me a couple of times! Its awesome and easy to make! We also make a Hershey bar pie. Take Hershey bars with almonds and melt..Save one Hershey bar... add 1/2 a tub of cool whip and whip into a graham cracker pie crust! Put the rest of the cool whip on top and grate the extra bar on top! Very easy!

made the pie last night and added the chocolate chips and some banana slices

Oh, I just made this with pumpkin butter last night and it worked marvelously. Add in a teaspoon and a bit of pumpkin pie spice. And I suspect that if pumpkin butter worked, then apple butter would too.

Reese's pie at the Koffee Kup in Hico. You'll thank me.

mmmm. what's cookie butter and can you make a sammich with it?

Cookie butter, Trader Joes. Who knew?

Think the texture of peanut butter, but flavored like a really good snickerdoodle. Yes, you can make a sandwich with it. It's at Kroger and HEB next to the peanut butter. I like to dip apple slices in it.



Uh huh, and this is how to make a whole pie for less than they charge you for a single slice... and you don't have to drive to Hico to get it.

IS it HEAVY CREAM or Cream Cheese ???
these are different things.

I'll retype it...

1 block cream cheese
1/2 cup sugar.
1 cup peanut butter
2 tablespoons vanilla
And either a tub of cool whip or 8 ounces of whipped cream.

Does that make more sense?

Awesome!

.... GREAT .....
be sure to use FISHER peanut butter.

I'll post my recipe for a very easy peanut butter "FUDGE"
just in time for the holidays.

My wife made this with oreo cookie crust and it was great.

This is one I regularly have to “forget” how to make. It’s too good especially when it is made with cookie butter.

what is cookie butter?

Imagine peanut butter consistency but tastes like snickerdoodles.

Cut up some of those tiny marshmello's and fold in......

My favorite. Going to giv your recipe a try.

Sounds great

Great peanut butter pie recipe Kattelyn. Made it this morning and just had my first taste.👍

Wonderful!

Love peanut butter and a whole pie made with it sounds perfect.

The best thing about this pie is....
1. Absolutely delicious
2. Healthy
3. Low calorie
4. Goes well with all diets
5. So easy to make
6. Did I mention this pie is very health, diet, and calorie conscious.


Negatives
1. Tends to bring out selfishness
2. Tends to bring out sneakiness, ie... hiding pie from others.
3. May lead to violence when down to last piece.

Man, that sounds GOOD! Now I have something to do tomorrow while it's raining!!!

Wonderful. Made it today.
Thanks Kattelyn.

You're most welcome! It always makes me happy to hear people liked my recipes!