Texas Fishing Forum

Gar in neighborhood lake

Posted By: MONSTER2

Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/10/21 12:21 AM

Does anyone know if the companies that manage neighborhood lakes ever stock gar? I’ve never seen a gar in the local lake I fish, and for the past 2 days they’re everywhere. The swim and feed like a pack of wolves through the shallow plants. I watched a guy use a net and he caught 3 decent sized ones in one try (released).

I’m wondering if they were added to the lake for some sort of benefit, or if they’ve always been there but all of a sudden have become active. I don’t know what else in these lakes are so over abundant that they would need to be controlled, except maybe the turtles.

Attached picture AAF56260-D08A-4C7B-8903-D22E7E2AFA84.jpeg
Attached picture BA74DC0F-AD86-48B1-9E8B-53F964C7FD00.jpeg
Posted By: Bruce Allen

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/10/21 12:37 AM

they bunch up in shallows during the spring to spawn.. they are usually deeper so you don't really see them except when they are feeding in the shallows.
Posted By: MONSTER2

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/10/21 04:00 AM

Good to know...thanks for the education. They seem ravenous at the moment, unaware of what’s going on around them. I tapped one on the back w my rod this afternoon and it didn’t even flinch. The other end of the lake is deeper. I guess they’ve been hanging out over there until recently.
Posted By: banker-always fishing

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/10/21 04:02 AM

It would surprise me if gar would be stocked in a neighborhood lake. Eggs had to transferred there by other means via birds etc. Some could have been released there after being caught at a different water body. Also if the lake is fed by a creek they could have entered in through the creek. noidea Anyway enjoy them. They are very good fighters. boxing
Posted By: MONSTER2

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/10/21 05:15 PM

Haven’t gotten them to hit my spoon yet...maybe a cut bait would work better. They almost look like eels the way they bunch up and slide through the shallows. I was more afraid that they would gobble up all the bait fish and make life harder on the LMB and crappie. If they’ve been there all this time anyway, I guess Mother Nature has worked out the balance. Thanks for the input.
Posted By: Lee Finlay

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/10/21 06:39 PM

I've had good luck catching them with small light colored moving baits, like white grubs.
Posted By: Darin S.

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/11/21 12:56 AM

Originally Posted by MONSTER2
Haven’t gotten them to hit my spoon yet...maybe a cut bait would work better. They almost look like eels the way they bunch up and slide through the shallows. I was more afraid that they would gobble up all the bait fish and make life harder on the LMB and crappie. If they’ve been there all this time anyway, I guess Mother Nature has worked out the balance. Thanks for the input.


I recommend removing them. They eat bass and crappie.
Posted By: banker-always fishing

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/11/21 02:24 AM

Use cut bait! Works every time. hooked
Posted By: MONSTER2

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/12/21 04:23 AM

Got one to hit my lure today but didn’t hook up. They seem to be feeding non-stop.
Posted By: Bad93ex

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/12/21 01:38 PM

Originally Posted by banker-always fishing
It would surprise me if gar would be stocked in a neighborhood lake. Eggs had to transferred there by other means via birds etc. Some could have been released there after being caught at a different water body. Also if the lake is fed by a creek they could have entered in through the creek. noidea Anyway enjoy them. They are very good fighters. boxing


Most likely transferred in by birds.
Posted By: Jack Enidus

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/12/21 01:44 PM

Originally Posted by MONSTER2
I was more afraid that they would gobble up all the bait fish and make life harder on the LMB and crappie.


This is the excuse bow "fishing" psychopaths use for going out and killing them en masse. They actually have very low metabolisms and spend most months of the year dormant and suspended on the bottom.
Posted By: Flip-n-go

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/12/21 01:47 PM

^^^^ You're an idiot.
Posted By: jaymzinsa

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/12/21 05:27 PM

Go on youtube and look up how to make a rope lure. Gar cant resist them, best way to catch gar in my opinion.
Posted By: Jack Enidus

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/13/21 04:34 AM

Originally Posted by Flip-n-go
^^^^ You're an idiot.


TPW did a big article on gar (specifically alligator gar) in one of their magazine issues a few years ago. There's a lot of misinformation out there and TPW spends a good amount of money for research and awareness towards ending the senseless slaughter of the species. I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that the biologists who actually study those fish are better experts than Joe Schmo with a Bow.

https://tpwmagazine.com/archive/2015/mar/ed_3_gar/

Quote
“It’s a unique fish, a misunderstood fish, and it’s had an unfounded bad rap,” says Dave Terre, chief of fisheries management and research at the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department.


Quote
Department biologists have conducted a dozen studies so far... TPWD biologists analyzed the stomach contents of 392 gator gar... and found carp, tilapia and shad... and found carp, tilapia and shad... largemouth bass accounting for only 8 percent. Studies at six other Texas reservoirs, dating back to 1970, showed even smaller percentages of bass in the gars’ diet, and there’s no evidence that the big fish are having a significant impact on bass populations.


Quote
Terre notes that many of the state’s best bass lakes — Falcon, Choke Canyon, Sam Rayburn and Toledo Bend — have robust populations of alligator gar.

“These fish have coexisted for eons,” he points out. “We can and do have great fishing for largemouth bass and alligator gar in the same place at the same time.”


I have nothing against folks who legally harvest the fish by following the size and possession limits. It's the poachers who go out and fill trashcans and dump them in a field somewhere for a picture to post to an archery fishing forum on Facebook that are the problem and also the first ones to perpetuate the myth that they're doing it for the bass.
Posted By: ChanceHuiet

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/13/21 10:49 AM

Originally Posted by Jack Enidus
Originally Posted by Flip-n-go
^^^^ You're an idiot.


TPW did a big article on gar (specifically alligator gar) in one of their magazine issues a few years ago. There's a lot of misinformation out there and TPW spends a good amount of money for research and awareness towards ending the senseless slaughter of the species. I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that the biologists who actually study those fish are better experts than Joe Schmo with a Bow.

https://tpwmagazine.com/archive/2015/mar/ed_3_gar/

Quote
“It’s a unique fish, a misunderstood fish, and it’s had an unfounded bad rap,” says Dave Terre, chief of fisheries management and research at the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department.


Quote
Department biologists have conducted a dozen studies so far... TPWD biologists analyzed the stomach contents of 392 gator gar... and found carp, tilapia and shad... and found carp, tilapia and shad... largemouth bass accounting for only 8 percent. Studies at six other Texas reservoirs, dating back to 1970, showed even smaller percentages of bass in the gars’ diet, and there’s no evidence that the big fish are having a significant impact on bass populations.


Quote
Terre notes that many of the state’s best bass lakes — Falcon, Choke Canyon, Sam Rayburn and Toledo Bend — have robust populations of alligator gar.

“These fish have coexisted for eons,” he points out. “We can and do have great fishing for largemouth bass and alligator gar in the same place at the same time.”


I have nothing against folks who legally harvest the fish by following the size and possession limits. It's the poachers who go out and fill trashcans and dump them in a field somewhere for a picture to post to an archery fishing forum on Facebook that are the problem and also the first ones to perpetuate the myth that they're doing it for the bass.




Yet again your an idiot. The "poachers" that have following the law until it recently changed about alligator gar. Can still fill buckets of carp and Buffalo and other species of gar. All perfectly legal. BUT to dump them in a field to rot is illegal. I've gone with a whole lot of people and nobody I know does this. Personally 99% of our fish gets ground up and used in gardens and feeding a family friends pigs. They love that stuff.
Posted By: ToasterWEyes

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/13/21 03:57 PM

Originally Posted by Jack Enidus
Originally Posted by MONSTER2
I was more afraid that they would gobble up all the bait fish and make life harder on the LMB and crappie.


This is the excuse bow "fishing" psychopaths use for going out and killing them en masse. They actually have very low metabolisms and spend most months of the year dormant and suspended on the bottom.


Hello from a bow fishing psycho!

[Linked Image]
Posted By: ToasterWEyes

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/13/21 03:59 PM

Wack em and stack em.

[Linked Image]
Posted By: Darin S.

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/13/21 09:52 PM

Originally Posted by Jack Enidus
Originally Posted by Flip-n-go
^^^^ You're an idiot.


TPW did a big article on gar (specifically alligator gar) in one of their magazine issues a few years ago. There's a lot of misinformation out there and TPW spends a good amount of money for research and awareness towards ending the senseless slaughter of the species. I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that the biologists who actually study those fish are better experts than Joe Schmo with a Bow.

https://tpwmagazine.com/archive/2015/mar/ed_3_gar/

Quote
“It’s a unique fish, a misunderstood fish, and it’s had an unfounded bad rap,” says Dave Terre, chief of fisheries management and research at the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department.


Quote
Department biologists have conducted a dozen studies so far... TPWD biologists analyzed the stomach contents of 392 gator gar... and found carp, tilapia and shad... and found carp, tilapia and shad... largemouth bass accounting for only 8 percent. Studies at six other Texas reservoirs, dating back to 1970, showed even smaller percentages of bass in the gars’ diet, and there’s no evidence that the big fish are having a significant impact on bass populations.


Quote
Terre notes that many of the state’s best bass lakes — Falcon, Choke Canyon, Sam Rayburn and Toledo Bend — have robust populations of alligator gar.

“These fish have coexisted for eons,” he points out. “We can and do have great fishing for largemouth bass and alligator gar in the same place at the same time.”


I have nothing against folks who legally harvest the fish by following the size and possession limits. It's the poachers who go out and fill trashcans and dump them in a field somewhere for a picture to post to an archery fishing forum on Facebook that are the problem and also the first ones to perpetuate the myth that they're doing it for the bass.



Go look at the studies PAWS did at Falcon for a couple of years on alligator gar. The experts came to the conclusion that they were a detriment to to the fishery since all they do is eat, reproduce and have no predators. They decided to change the bag limit from 1 to 5 at Falcon. FIVE A DAY,
Posted By: Darin S.

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/13/21 10:07 PM

We all know those little needle nosed gar pictured will try to eat the baby’s of the bass,crappie, bluegill. In a lake no biggie but you don’t want those suckers in a neighborhood pond!
Posted By: ToasterWEyes

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/14/21 01:37 AM

This subject has been beaten to death. Bottom line, TPWD deems this huge harvests as beneficial or at the very least not detrimental to the state’s fisheries or they’d shut it down. Simple as that. I promise my bow fishing boat doesn’t blend into the surroundings at night......
Posted By: MONSTER2

Re: Gar in neighborhood lake - 04/14/21 06:16 PM

This neighborhood lake isn't super small, but it's shallow except for the far end. Since I started this post, the gar are now everywhere. They just cruise by the shoreline barely noticing me (or my jig).

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]
© 2024 Texas Fishing Forum