I have heard that they collect a year or so worth of fishing reports and just recycle the same reports over and over. Can anyone verify this?
Definitely not true. The reports are done under a contract for TPWD by a private agency which collects current reports from its sources.
Some of the sources are marina operators and others who depend upon the fishing public for a living. Those people are going to understandably be reluctant to report the fishing is lousy. On the whole the reporters try to give an accurate report, and if the reports are consistently poor in quality the reporters are replaced.
There is a time lag of about a week in the process which accounts for some of the problems. By the way, the owners of this forum are also the people who do the reports. I think they do a good job and we should be grateful for them.