The mercury optimax oil is recommended for the optimax. The premium or premium plus should only be substituted in the optimax if there is no optimax dfi oil available.
The premium plus is to be ran in the pro xs.
It has something to do with the "thickness" of the oil and the engines ability to pull oil/lubricate the head, especially during cooler weather.
That is basically what I found while researching this subject, but I'm guessing there's not much difference, however I would run what your owners manual says to run. That being said I ran amsoil in my opti