Ok--
you want to go with one of the " light tackle " boats. It is
not hard to catch 10-12 species in a single day. I like fishing
the wrecks on the gulf side. Anchor up and chunk a net full
of pilchards over the wreck and a feeding frenzy starts
immeadiately.
The guide I used for several years is no longer fishing.
Check with the guys over on this forum ,
http://outdoorsbest.zeroforum.com/zeromain?id=1 I would strongly recommend a private charter, the " head
boats " are for tourists. They will take you to the
reef and you will fish the whole time in one spot for
yellowtail snapper ( 12 inches is a big one ) with a
bunch of drunks.
Now for the must do's while in Key West,
drink a beer at Sloppy's Joes and Irish Kevin's on
Duval street.
At least one meal at A%B Lobster House.
If you have a car, it is worth the time to drive up
to Islamorada (75m north ) and go to Robie's ( search youtube for feeding the tarpon at Robie's)
This place is new since I've been there , but it looks
interesting. Marathon is about 45 miles from KW.
http://www.marathonaquaranch.com/index.html If you don't have a great time in KW , it is your own
damn fault .

Mo