I prefer Concord Grape.

Absolutely, grape

Home aide plum

Grape

None, jelly sucks

Grape is the first choice. Strawberry preserves is a second.

honey first, jalapeno jelly from atwoods second.

jalapeno jelly/cream cheese/pb/toasted whole wheat bread.

special occasions only.

+ 1 grape

Mayhaw jelly - delicious

Blackberry preserves.

Haven’t eaten it in a few years but strawberry was my choice!

Peanut butter and banana sandwich

Strawberry with extra crunchy peanut butter

Speaking of sandwiches, I got an epic one in few days

With fresh, soft white bread!

Jam

Strawberry preserves and extra crunchy Jifs. Grape jelly would be second choice.

Smucker's Pineapple or Blueberry Preserves... the Peanut butter has to be Jiff Extra Crunchy...

Yep. Gotta be the crunchy Peter Pan.

Blenheim apricot with almond butter on Jewish rye.

https://ilovepeanutbutter.com/

Y'all should try this peanut butter. It's really good and sugar isn't added to most, if not all, their products.

I go with Strawberry Jam or Preserves (Apricot Preserves a close second), wife goes with Honey. No jelly in our house.

Yeah soft bread is an absolute must.

Homemade cherry jam.

This.

+1

When you can find it.
Pineapple/apricot is magic with jiff peanut butter.

Thank a Cajun when you also discover it.

Yup...everything else is woke

I used to eat only concord grape. Then I tried Smucker's Seedless Blackberry Jam - it's now my go to for PB&J and biscuits

Butter

strawberry or peach preserves. Jelly sucks.

Grape jelly and Peter Pan peanut butter smooth

I am an expert on this as I challenged myself to eat a peanut butter sandwich every day for lunch for as long as I could stand it (made it two years almost to the day).

I varied multiple peanut butters, bread types, multiple jams, preserves, honeys, etc. to make this possible. I never hit a wall or found this challenge truly difficult; but on the very last day, I just looked at the sandwich and had zero interest in eating it and threw it in the garbage can.

The best pbj is as follows:
Thin Guerrero flour tortilla…very lightly toasted
Creamy Jif
Marmalade

You want the thinnest bread that can contain the peanut butter without it getting on your hands.
You want high peanut butter and jam to bread ratio

Peanut butter…started out with a strong Extra crunchy preference, but after the first nine months, I switched to smooth and never looked back…less chance of needing a tooth pick

Jelly/jam—you want something citrus or sharp to cut through the sweetness of the peanut butter.
Orange, lemon, pineapple, raspberry, blackberry, peach preserves are great to contrast with the peanut butter.

Ketchup give it a try

Homemade

This

Smucker Strawberry Jam

I stopped eating pb and j when I was about 12.

Blueberry preserves

Never liked PB&J sandwiches. When I was young we ate PB on buttered bread topped with brown sugar open faced. Growing up in Wisconsin it was real butter. Margarine was not legal to sell in Wisconsin back then.

apricot preserves

Yep!

A good Red Plum is hard to beat.

there should be a Jelly / Jam / Preserve poll ....

When I was young we always had jelly from my grandma (she raised me). Usually dewberry that we picked locally. I like grape too. We did have a lot of fig preserves but that was not my fav. We had hyper-productive fig trees.

Mrs RayBob is more a jam fan so it is mostly strawberry. We're jammers. Don't eat a lot of PB&J though. Hot buttered biscuits and I can hurt myself with jam.

Raspberry Preserves

Peanut butter at least 1/2" thick
Jelly is Strawberry preserves, Rasberry preserves, or Concord grape

any jelly will do as will honey but if I'm choosing - 1. Grape 2. Strawberry 3. Blueberry

one of my students brought me a jar of Christmas jelly, made from cranberries..that works too

Never met a PBJ I didn't like. Bonus points if it has Lays or Ruffles potato chips in it too.

You need Jesus.

LOL

Mint Apple

AMEN !

Sweet and salty is as good as it gets!

Wild Plum

No jelly...and never grape ever.
1st choice raspberry preserves
After that almost any fruit preserves or jam.

AND the PB must be chunky.
Smooth PB is for kiddies and ladies.

Smooth PB is for guys that wear trench coats and hang out at shifty places.

LOL

Grape and crunchy PB


Every other jelly occasion I want strawberry or plum or anything seedless and not grape

I will be going whole hog on the spicy jelly for lunch tomorrow.

I have some habanero jelly that I have not tasted, yet.

stay tuned!

Aw man almost forgot about the dewberries we used to pick for jelly when we lived in East Texas.
Best homemade jelly ever!

exactly.. the crunchy peanut butter eaters are all fart knockers

Strawberry

+1

Grape... Dan

Blackberry

Grandma's Muscadine. It was the best.