No yes no maybe.
First you’re going to lose 300-400 rpms with your other prop setup as is.
3 1/2” is probably going to be too high. Your V4 doesn’t twist as large a prop as a V6 so it just can’t run as high.
The correct answer is find another 19 stainless for your motor, that aluminum can never find potential.
Then take the time with a fishing load to find your right spot. Set it where it is and raise 1/4” at a time until you lose lift, speed or water pressure. The only way to do it right.
Marble Falls/Seadrift TX