Main Menu
Advertisement
Affiliates
Advertisement
Newest Members
5lbtest, Short fuse 8_5, flymt, ken1, bbrandog
106356 Registered Users
Top Posters
TexDawg 86916
hopalong 78789
Pilothawk 75561
JDavis7873® 67385
John175 ® 65721
FattyMcButterpants 60793
Derek 🐝 58856
Tritonman 57718
LoneStarSon® 53703
SkeeterRonnie 53102
facebook
Forum Stats
106356 Members
61 Forums
811871 Topics
10250017 Posts

Max Online: 36273 @ 01/23/13 02:34 PM
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
#12285173 - 06/08/17 05:31 PM Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both)
Dr. Chase Offline
TFF Team Angler

Registered: 04/17/06
Posts: 3773
Loc: Benbrook/Granbury/Whitney/Stil...
Anyone have experience with both? If so, which one has been a better motor for you?

Top
#12285218 - 06/08/17 06:12 PM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: Dr. Chase]
epicoutdoors Offline
Extreme Angler

Registered: 02/18/08
Posts: 1945
Loc: On The Water NE Texas
I have a 2017 250 Pro XS on my new boat and I owned a 2014 model also. The Merc's have been very reliable for me and run strong. I have no complaints on them. That being said, I had a 2015 250 SHO and I will go back to a Yamaha on my next boat. Three things that make the difference in my experience with the SHO. First, not having to constantly add two stroke oil to the oil tank. Second, the SHO is very quiet, both idling and at speed. Third, the holeshot with the SHO is superior. I also find the SHO to be very close to the Pro XS in top end speed with maybe a 1 mph difference, boat for boat. 2cents

Top
#12285299 - 06/08/17 07:14 PM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: Dr. Chase]
GIG'EM AGGIES Online   content
Extreme Angler

Registered: 05/14/14
Posts: 2014
Loc: texas
I'm running a SHO on my Skeeter and love everything about it. Besides what epic said the thing just sips gas too.
_________________________
"Sometimes there just aren't enough rocks"
Forest Gump

Top
#12285327 - 06/08/17 07:33 PM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: Dr. Chase]
Troutnout Offline
Angler

Registered: 05/31/14
Posts: 315
I've owned a 250 Pro XS and currently a 250 SHO. My Merc ran like a sclalded ape... it had several issues but all was taken care of under warranty. So far, the Yamaha has been great. 3 years no issues. SHO has better holeshot becasue it's a 4 stroke... Merc a few mph faster, Merc better fuel mileage.... SHO quiet, and no oil.... Depending on what you want, they are both good motors.
_________________________
Official Wannabe

Top
#12285332 - 06/08/17 07:40 PM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: Dr. Chase]
Ken A. Offline
TFF Celebrity

Registered: 10/02/06
Posts: 8582
Loc: Trophy Club, TX
I agree with all the above. Both are great engines.

Top
#12285335 - 06/08/17 07:42 PM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: Dr. Chase]
Stompy Offline
Extreme Angler

Registered: 03/22/10
Posts: 1009
Loc: Breckenridge Tx
Both great engines, can't go wrong either way. That being said, I love my SHO
_________________________
www.jaranchhunting.com
Cabin Rentals on the ranch for Hubbard Creek Lake

Top
#12285398 - 06/08/17 08:31 PM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: Dr. Chase]
Kapnbill Offline
Angler

Registered: 06/30/02
Posts: 323
Loc: Austin
I've owned both. My experience was similar to above. Better hole shot with SHO. Similar top ends. I found that routine service and parts were less expensive with the Merc, and far more Merc shops than Yamaha shops for service. Both are good motors.

Top
#12285439 - 06/08/17 08:58 PM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: Troutnout]
tmd11111 Online   content
Angler

Registered: 04/30/17
Posts: 409
Loc: San Angelo
Originally Posted By: Troutnout
I've owned a 250 Pro XS and currently a 250 SHO. My Merc ran like a sclalded ape... it had several issues but all was taken care of under warranty. So far, the Yamaha has been great. 3 years no issues. SHO has better holeshot becasue it's a 4 stroke... Merc a few mph faster, Merc better fuel mileage.... SHO quiet, and no oil.... Depending on what you want, they are both good motors.


The SHO has a better hole shot because it has almost 50% more displacement not because its a 4 stroke.

Top
#12285457 - 06/08/17 09:07 PM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: Dr. Chase]
Andrew Y'Barbo Offline
Extreme Angler

Registered: 06/25/12
Posts: 1345
Loc: Lufkin Texas
I love the simplicity of the sho. Ive also learned that there is a difference on top end but it's minor. If a man is willing to properly set up a boat. It's very competitive.

Top
#12285464 - 06/08/17 09:12 PM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: tmd11111]
Dr. Chase Offline
TFF Team Angler

Registered: 04/17/06
Posts: 3773
Loc: Benbrook/Granbury/Whitney/Stil...
Originally Posted By: tmd11111
Originally Posted By: Troutnout
I've owned a 250 Pro XS and currently a 250 SHO. My Merc ran like a sclalded ape... it had several issues but all was taken care of under warranty. So far, the Yamaha has been great. 3 years no issues. SHO has better holeshot becasue it's a 4 stroke... Merc a few mph faster, Merc better fuel mileage.... SHO quiet, and no oil.... Depending on what you want, they are both good motors.


The SHO has a better hole shot because it has almost 50% more displacement not because its a 4 stroke.


Would a hydrolic jackplate be a variable to consider for the holeshot difference?

New model pro xs owners: how much oil are you going through? Like fishing every weekend?

Is having to do the oil changes in the SHO an advantage over going through all the gallons of 2 stroke oil?

Do you have to use the merc brand oil to keep your warranty on the pro xs?

Thanks for the responses.

Top
#12285524 - 06/08/17 09:45 PM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: Dr. Chase]
grout-scout Offline
TFF Celebrity

Registered: 12/08/08
Posts: 6361
Loc: Boerne, Texas
Anybody have the new evinrude g2? I'd love to hear a comparison about it vs the sho & merc.

Top
#12285688 - 06/09/17 01:44 AM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: Dr. Chase]
Dr. Chase Offline
TFF Team Angler

Registered: 04/17/06
Posts: 3773
Loc: Benbrook/Granbury/Whitney/Stil...
I know of several friends that had the early E techs with a bunch of of problems. I do see that a lot of the Basscat's that have any Evinrude motor seem to list cheaper and stay on the market for much longer than a Yamaha or Mercury. I guess the g2s look pretty cool, but I'd never consider their products.

PS-don't high jack my thread bro...

Top
#12285812 - 06/09/17 07:21 AM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: Dr. Chase]
921 Phoenix Offline
Extreme Angler

Registered: 06/21/11
Posts: 2483
Originally Posted By: Brazos Bass Cat
Originally Posted By: tmd11111
Originally Posted By: Troutnout
I've owned a 250 Pro XS and currently a 250 SHO. My Merc ran like a sclalded ape... it had several issues but all was taken care of under warranty. So far, the Yamaha has been great. 3 years no issues. SHO has better holeshot becasue it's a 4 stroke... Merc a few mph faster, Merc better fuel mileage.... SHO quiet, and no oil.... Depending on what you want, they are both good motors.


The SHO has a better hole shot because it has almost 50% more displacement not because its a 4 stroke.


Would a hydrolic jackplate be a variable to consider for the holeshot difference?

New model pro xs owners: how much oil are you going through? Like fishing every weekend?

Is having to do the oil changes in the SHO an advantage over going through all the gallons of 2 stroke oil?

Do you have to use the merc brand oil to keep your warranty on the pro xs?

Thanks for the responses.


The Hydraulic jack plate will help but the Sho is just a better hole shot.

You will use a gallon of oil per 50 gallons of fuel. I run a lot so I go through a gallon of oil every couple weeks when fishing hard. I would say I go through in a year about 24 gallons. I use the mercury premium at about 24 dollars or 576 dollars a year. The oil change is about 125 dollars if you have it done or about 60 if you do it your self. I fish a lot when I am fishing.

You just have to have use Tcw3 oil for the warranty.

just my .02

Top
#12285817 - 06/09/17 07:25 AM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: 921 Phoenix]
fouzman Offline
Methuselah

Registered: 01/20/09
Posts: 45854
Loc: Houston, TX
Originally Posted By: 921 Phoenix
Originally Posted By: Brazos Bass Cat
Originally Posted By: tmd11111
Originally Posted By: Troutnout
I've owned a 250 Pro XS and currently a 250 SHO. My Merc ran like a sclalded ape... it had several issues but all was taken care of under warranty. So far, the Yamaha has been great. 3 years no issues. SHO has better holeshot becasue it's a 4 stroke... Merc a few mph faster, Merc better fuel mileage.... SHO quiet, and no oil.... Depending on what you want, they are both good motors.


The SHO has a better hole shot because it has almost 50% more displacement not because its a 4 stroke.


Would a hydrolic jackplate be a variable to consider for the holeshot difference?

New model pro xs owners: how much oil are you going through? Like fishing every weekend?

Is having to do the oil changes in the SHO an advantage over going through all the gallons of 2 stroke oil?

Do you have to use the merc brand oil to keep your warranty on the pro xs?

Thanks for the responses.




You will use a gallon of oil per 50 gallons of fuel. I run a lot so I go through a gallon of oil every couple weeks when fishing hard.


Dang, I've burned 50 gallons in a day fishing deep and re-checking spots all day. That's FISHING hard. Not necessarily catching hard, though roflmao
_________________________
"Things turn out best for those who make the best of the way things turn out" - Zachary Troy Schrah - a young man with vision far beyond his years.

Top
#12285834 - 06/09/17 07:37 AM Re: Pro XS vs SHO (newer model years for both) [Re: Dr. Chase]
Ken A. Offline
TFF Celebrity

Registered: 10/02/06
Posts: 8582
Loc: Trophy Club, TX
Originally Posted By: Brazos Bass Cat
Originally Posted By: tmd11111
Originally Posted By: Troutnout
I've owned a 250 Pro XS and currently a 250 SHO. My Merc ran like a sclalded ape... it had several issues but all was taken care of under warranty. So far, the Yamaha has been great. 3 years no issues. SHO has better holeshot becasue it's a 4 stroke... Merc a few mph faster, Merc better fuel mileage.... SHO quiet, and no oil.... Depending on what you want, they are both good motors.


The SHO has a better hole shot because it has almost 50% more displacement not because its a 4 stroke.


Would a hydrolic jackplate be a variable to consider for the holeshot difference?

New model pro xs owners: how much oil are you going through? Like fishing every weekend?

Is having to do the oil changes in the SHO an advantage over going through all the gallons of 2 stroke oil?

Do you have to use the merc brand oil to keep your warranty on the pro xs?

Thanks for the responses.


Here is one more thing to consider when comparing the two.

The same exact boat with the Yam is $1800 more. That will buy you a lot of 2 stroke oil.

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >



© 1998-2017 OUTDOOR SITES NETWORK all rights reserved USA and Worldwide