If reds and trout is your desire crystal blue charters is great. When choosing a guide there are lots of good one and lots of not so good ones. I have been a guide for years and have seen it all. Best advice I can give you make sure they have a facebook page with recent trips. They will show if they have a history of success on the water or not. Alot of guides get a couple of good pics with lots of fish and a fancey websites but there avg day on the water isnt much to brag about.
Just take your time when choosing a guide. Now if you decide you want to go flounder gigging I am your guy my boat dont come in till we have our limits. www.nocturnalassault.com
you can see recent reports on the facebook page.