Ok, I catch loads of catfish on Lake Fork with Stubby's bait. Last week I ran out of Stubby's and dug out a can of DK punch bait. When catfish are biting well you can catch them on all bait. I also had some shrimp in my cooler. Let's just say I did get a few bites on the DK and shrimp. I found an old container that had a couple of hooks full of Stubby's bait and caught a nice one. I will tell you at least on Lake Fork, No other bait compares with Stubby's cheese bait.