LiveTarget Hollow Frog
If you ask me, this one has the softest body of them all. I believe my hookup percentage is around 75-80 percent, which is pretty dang good for a frog; and this is on long casts, in heavy slop. You can't beat the natural looking colors on these frogs either. Well worth the money if you ask me. Reaction Innovations Swamp Donkey
If you wanna talk about pure hookup ratio and not about body softness, then the Swamp Donkey should be your choice. I've noticed that my hookup percentage is right around 85-90 percent, which is about as good as you can ask for. The hooks on this frog come already bent up a little, which saves you time from having to do it yourself. The narrow body on this frog makes it walk super easy and also helps you when you hookup!