AJ, I thought the same thing. Got some Monkey Milk at Academy and tried them. I don't know if it is the tail action or what but they didn't hit it as well.
Jiggin, the first bunch I got from the Trout Magnet website, as their Crappie Magnet kit. I ordered three 50 packs of bodies only from ebay. I'm now just using 1/8oz unpainted jig heads. I use super glue to hold the body to the head. The first fish I caught on this were sandies. After the first couple of fish pulling the body off the jig, it was so torn up I had to replace it. I had some super glue from jig bodies I got from Lane Palmer, and started using it. I can now use one body pretty much until I lose it in the brush. I hope to start getting a better feel for the brush and not lose to many more.
"I'd rather be fishing!"