Nope, soap and brush won't get it off Smithaven. Fast Orange might do it, but I probably won't order a big bottle of it. Maybe I can find a small bottle in a local store. Thanks for the replies.
It's like jeffnsa said, a combination of dirt and fish slime, I get the same problem.If it's really bad I have to push the Fast Orange into my fingernails wash my hands twice.Most places should carry small bottles of Fast Orange.