106762 Members
61 Forums
817104 Topics
10321747 Posts
Max Online: 36273 @ 01/23/13 02:34 PM


#10904840  06/09/15 06:31 AM
Math (statistics) class and fishing

Extreme Angler
Registered: 03/09/15
Posts: 1614
Loc: Texas

I may get banned for this! No, seriously, a few of you may find it interesting. Its roots lie in the "we were both doing the exact same thing but he caught 5 fish and I caught none" rubric. Then, the statement is followed by something like "he was throwing a blue fleck with a chartreuse tail, mine was just blue fleck" or something like that. Then, the result is supposed to be attributable to the chartreuse tail paint. Maybe, maybe not. We all know, should know, that means almost nothing, that there is a randomness to things that competes with skills making it hard to determine how to account for end results. But, if you hand a fair coin to 1024 people in an auditorium, one of them, statistically, will flip all heads or tails over 10 flips. In this case, it has nothing to do with skill, all luck. So, I changed the odds to "1 in 10" for some fishing presentation, gosh I wish, and I ran a study of what the results would look like for two fisherman, equally skilled, fishing sidebyside, each with a 1 in 10 chance of catching a fish on each cast. One in ten over a thousand casts? Statistically, that should net out 100 catches for each fisherman, but how often would each of them end up with the same fish total? The way I set it up in Excel, I could "pulse" my result over and over but the graph I created would always look about the same, a sort of normal distribution. The result, over a thousand casts, two fisherman both caught the same number of fish slightly less than 10% of the time (look for the zero label). It falls off to each side viewing it from the perspective of one of the fisherman, the number of times he does way better or way worse than his partner. Anyway, in a nutshell, one can go ahead and assume it is all about a worm color that day, or line color, or, or, or . . . the list is endless. But, there is always that randomness to consider. Class over. Take a look at the little chart. The number labels at each point are zero for the percentage of time with the same result and then one guy's over and underperformance. Brad

Top



#10904856  06/09/15 06:39 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Brad R]

TFF Guru
Registered: 02/28/04
Posts: 17493
Loc: Flower Mound, TX

I hated statistics in school and still do. Let's talk about a cold beer while fishing and determine the probability of catching a quicker buzz with 3.2 vs 5.0% by volume.
_________________________
2007 Skeeter 20i w/ 250 HPDI

Top



#10904872  06/09/15 06:54 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Brad R]

Extreme Angler
Registered: 02/11/10
Posts: 2013
Loc: Arlington,Tx

You are correct you should be banned.
_________________________

Top



#10905031  06/09/15 08:23 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Brad R]

Extreme Angler
Registered: 03/09/15
Posts: 1614
Loc: Texas

It'll have to wait before I ban myself: I am drinking a beer and ordering worms with chartreuse tail tips!
Ha! Brad

Top



#10905039  06/09/15 08:28 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Brad R]

TFF Guru
Registered: 03/24/14
Posts: 12675
Loc: North Texas

How dare you make me think about math on a bass fishing forum!
(Seriously, though, that's interesting stuff. I wish I was better at statistics.)
_________________________

Top



#10905046  06/09/15 08:32 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Brad R]

Extreme Angler
Registered: 03/09/15
Posts: 1614
Loc: Texas

Oh! What set this off was a few recent posts about KVD and I wondered to myself since all of the great bass anglers have great boats, great equipment and great stuff, whether what he does is sort of "out Billy Ball" other anglers. In essence, does he just "get" ways to create edges and then apply them?
I don't know, but if I were a million dollar a year professional bass angler, or wanting to be one, I think I'd hire the equivalent of a sabermetrician ( a baseball stat dude) to try to find every little statistical advantage I could take advantage of.
I can think of 20 or more stats I'd want to know from raw data that we otherwise just act intuitively on. Nothing wrong with intuition, but a dab of science/math likely wouldn't hurt.
Anyway . . . Brad

Top



#10905113  06/09/15 08:57 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Brad R]

Extreme Angler
Registered: 01/15/10
Posts: 2285

Man, you're trying to rattle some cages this morning! I like the mathematical side of things!

Top



#10905140  06/09/15 09:08 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Brad R]

Extreme Angler
Registered: 02/19/07
Posts: 1275
Loc: Hawley, TX

I don't know, but if I were a million dollar a year professional bass angler, or wanting to be one, I think I'd hire the equivalent of a sabermetrician ( a baseball stat dude) to try to find every little statistical advantage I could take advantage of.
I can think of 20 or more stats I'd want to know from raw data that we otherwise just act intuitively on. Nothing wrong with intuition, but a dab of science/math likely wouldn't hurt.
I'm so with you on this. I don't know of anyone who has looked at fishing behavior from a scientific or statistical standpoint in order to improve performance. There's room for it in the industry, I bet. You could be the first fishometrics consultant

Top



#10905156  06/09/15 09:13 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Jkf96a]

Pro Angler
Registered: 01/14/09
Posts: 620
Loc: Kingwood, TX

Got a A in stat after getting C's on all 3 tests in college.
With worm color and casts, they are "mutually exclusive', the outcome of one has no impact on the outcome of another.
But I agree, lets do the 3.5 and 5% challenge and see who wins, lot more fun than imperical rules or chebysevs (sp?) method.
_________________________
Watch it happen, make it happen, or say what the hell happened. Capt. Phil Harris F/V Cornelia Marie RIP

Top



#10905167  06/09/15 09:18 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Brad R]

Extreme Angler
Registered: 10/09/01
Posts: 2900
Loc: Lubbock, Texas.

With a PhD. in Statatistics, I applaud your thought process, but as mentioned every cast whether a fish bit or not is mutually expclusive to all other casts, UNLESS you are into a school of biting fish, then there would have to be some subset of factors to either ignore or not interpret those occasions. THIS is why I keep exquisite logs and it does pay off, quite often. Hope this helps.
Tight lines, keep safe and good luck.
Thad Rains
_________________________
Tight lines, keep safe and good luck.
Thad Rains

Top



#10905177  06/09/15 09:20 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Brad R]

Outdoorsman
Registered: 02/01/14
Posts: 120
Loc: TX, USA, Atlanta

I guess the number of casts is not more than 200300 per competition. It would be even more interesting.
_________________________
still learning

Top



#10905261  06/09/15 09:47 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Brad R]

Extreme Angler
Registered: 06/21/09
Posts: 1067
Loc: Ray Hubbard

I love bass fishing. And I love math. But I don't know if I love bass fishing math! But seriously, this is the kind of stuff that can keep advancing the sport. Keep up the good work!

Top



#10905368  06/09/15 10:28 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Thad Rains]

TFF Guru
Registered: 03/24/14
Posts: 12675
Loc: North Texas

With a PhD. in Statatistics, I applaud your thought process, but as mentioned every cast whether a fish bit or not is mutually expclusive to all other casts, UNLESS you are into a school of biting fish, then there would have to be some subset of factors to either ignore or not interpret those occasions. THIS is why I keep exquisite logs and it does pay off, quite often. Hope this helps.
Tight lines, keep safe and good luck.
Thad Rains Good for you. I had to drop statistics twice in college and take an alternative for my math credits (I'm terrible in math, obviously). What do you do, if you don't mind me asking? Do you use your PHD?
_________________________

Top



#10905373  06/09/15 10:29 AM
Re: Math (statistics) class and fishing
[Re: Brad R]

Extreme Angler
Registered: 03/09/15
Posts: 1614
Loc: Texas

I'll try some more math stuff, then.
Yes, each cast is mutually exclusive, just like flipping a coin. For that one person, statistically, in a group of 1024 who flips a coin all heads or tails ten straight times? His or her next flip is STILL a 50/50 outcome using a fair coin.
My greater point was to show via randomness that there should be no expectation of equal outcomes, that then we shouldn't read too much into why our results are better or worse than our partner's and start changing things, variables.
I'm fighting the silliness of "I used XXX line one time and my line snapped, so it must be all bad and I'll never use it again." We shouldn't think that "one time" is statistically relevant, but we are mostly inductive thinkers so we move along that way and away from the math stuff. So, one guy goes out and has a really good experience with power fishing, and that's all it takes; another guy doesn't and he swears off of it. It may have been randomness.
A Fishermatrician quiz:
If KVD is a well known power fisherman (he is) and with a trusted crankbait, has a 1 out of 30 catch rate (I'm making this up), but the fish he catches tend to be 1.1 times as large as, let's say, Aaron Marten's who is a wellknown finesse fisherman, who catches a fish dropshotting 1 out of 15 "drops," and KVD can make four times as many casts (it's a faster presentation so let's say 2 casts per minute) to Marten's drops, who on a statistical basis catches the biggest bag after the same unit of time, say 2 hours of fishing?
We don't have to know this, but if you have a $100,000 riding on the outcome, don't you think a pro ought to sort of make sure he is not too far off the best odds?
I'll post the answer later on.
Brad
Edited by Brad R (06/09/15 10:30 AM) Edit Reason: fix

Top



Moderator: buda13, chickenman, don the angler, FattyMcButterpants, Fish Killer, J2, Jons3825, NoconaBrian, RedSkeeter, Robbie Milam, Rockie Martin, Toontroller, Uncle Zeek, Weekender
